Is “She has three years working here” correct?
“She has three years working here.” is a sentence Spanish speakers often write. Here is what Yazzy says about it.
No. Say:
She has three years been working here for three years.
Present perfectUse present perfect continuous for an action still happening.
In SpanishUsa presente perfecto continuo para una acción que sigue.
MeaningElla lleva tres años trabajando aquí.
macOS 14+ · 4.1 MB · freeiPhone app: coming soon · email me at launch
About this mistake: Tense
English chooses the tense by time: the past simple for a finished time (yesterday, last week), the present perfect for a period up to now (for three years, since 2019), and the plain present after when / after / once for the future.
Spanish speakers often write it this way because Spanish says the same idea differently. See the mistakes Spanish speakers often make.
Practice: is this one correct?
The same kind of mistake in a different sentence, checked by Yazzy. Decide first, then open the answer.
“My son has two years studying English.”
Show Yazzy's fix
My son has two years been studying English for two years.
Present perfectUse this form for an action that continues now.
In SpanishUsa esta forma para una acción que continúa ahora.
The same mistake, from a German speaker
Since when do you work here?
Since when do have you work worked here?
Present perfectUse present perfect for time from past to now.
GermanFür Zeit von früher bis jetzt nimmt man Present Perfect.
Is “Since when do you work here” correct? →Another sentence Spanish speakers write
Do you know where is the office
Do you know where is the office is?
Question word orderUse normal word order after “Do you know.”
SpanishUsa orden normal después de “Do you know”.
Is “Do you know where is the office” correct? →Same kind of mistake, other languages
More sentences Spanish speakers ask about
Where it shows up at work
Check your own sentence
Select any sentence on your Mac and press ⌘D, or paste it into the iPhone app. Or try the sentence checker.
Questions
Is “She has three years working here” correct?
No. Say “She has been working here for three years.” Use present perfect continuous for an action still happening.
What is the correct way to say “She has three years working here”?
“She has been working here for three years.”
Send your next message with confidence.
Free to start. Set up in a minute.
macOS 14+ · 4.1 MB · freeiPhone app: coming soon · email me at launch
Free: 10 checks a day · No account